Save
This spooky eyeball brownie recipe transforms ordinary chocolate treats into delightfully creepy Halloween desserts that will be the star of any monster mash. The contrast between rich chocolate brownies, smooth white chocolate, and those staring candy eyes creates a visual treat that tastes as good as it looks frightful.
I first made these for my nephew's monster-themed birthday party, and they were such a hit that they've become our official Halloween tradition. Even my husband, who claims to dislike "fussy desserts," requests these every October.
Ingredients
- 1 box brownie mix: the foundation of your spooky treat, choose a fudgy variety for best results
- Additional ingredients listed on brownie box: usually eggs, oil, and water, follow package instructions for best texture
- 1/2 cup white chocolate chips: creates the eyeball base, high quality chips melt more smoothly
- Candy eyeballs: available in various sizes at craft stores or baking aisles during Halloween season
- Red gel icing: creates realistic bloodshot effect, gel works better than regular frosting for thin lines
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare The Base:
- Mix your brownie batter according to package instructions, being careful not to overmix which can make brownies tough. Pour the batter into a greased baking pan, spreading evenly to the corners for uniform thickness.
- Bake To Perfection:
- Follow the package directions for baking time, but start checking about 5 minutes early using the toothpick test. You want them fully baked but not dry. Allow to cool completely before decorating this usually takes at least 2 hours or they will melt your decorations.
- Create The Eyeball Base:
- Melt white chocolate chips in 30 second microwave intervals, stirring between each until smooth. Spread this evenly over the cooled brownies to create a clean white canvas for your eyeballs. Work quickly as the chocolate will begin to set.
- Add The Eyeballs:
- Place candy eyeballs across the white chocolate surface while it's still slightly soft so they adhere properly. You can arrange them in a pattern or randomly for a more chaotic look.
- Create Bloodshot Effect:
- Using red gel icing, carefully draw thin lines radiating outward from each eyeball. Start close to the pupil and extend outward, varying the thickness and direction for a realistic bloodshot appearance.
Save
My favorite part about making these is watching guests do a double take when they see the platter. My daughter now insists on being my assistant decorator, carefully placing each eyeball just so and always sneaking a few extra candy eyes for snacking.
Storage Tips
These eyeball brownies maintain their spooky appeal for 3 days when stored in an airtight container at room temperature. For longer storage, place them in the refrigerator where they'll stay fresh for up to a week, though the candy eyes may begin to soften slightly. I recommend placing wax paper between layers if stacking to prevent the decorations from smudging.
Creative Variations
Take these eyeball brownies to the next level by trying different decorative approaches. Use green or blue gel food coloring to tint the white chocolate for alien eyes. Add chocolate cookie crumbles around the edges for a dirt effect, suggesting eyes emerging from the grave. For an extra spooky touch, cut the brownies into coffin shapes using a template before decorating with the eyeballs.
Make Ahead Strategy
These brownies are perfect for preparing in advance of Halloween parties. Bake and cool the brownies completely up to two days before your event. Store them well wrapped at room temperature. Complete the decorating process the day before or morning of your gathering for the freshest appearance. The finished eyeball brownies actually look better after the decorations have had a few hours to set.
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I make these brownies from scratch instead of using a mix?
Absolutely! Any homemade brownie recipe works perfectly as the base. Just ensure they're fully cooled before adding the white chocolate layer and decorations.
- → Where can I find candy eyeballs?
Candy eyeballs are available in the baking section of most grocery stores, craft stores like Michaels or Hobby Lobby, or online retailers. They're especially easy to find during the Halloween season.
- → How far in advance can I make these brownies?
You can prepare these 1-2 days in advance. Store them in an airtight container at room temperature. The gel decoration may bleed slightly if stored longer.
- → Can I freeze these decorated brownies?
It's best to freeze the plain brownies without decorations. Once thawed, add the white chocolate layer, candy eyes, and gel decorations for the best appearance.
- → What alternatives can I use for the red gel icing?
Red jam thinned with a little water, red food coloring mixed with corn syrup, or melted red candy melts all work as alternatives to create the bloodshot effect.
- → How do I get clean cuts when slicing these brownies?
Use a sharp knife dipped in hot water and wiped clean between cuts. This helps prevent the toppings from smearing and gives you neat, presentable servings.